Terraria item ID 5012. Terraria 1.4.5.7.
The Flaming Mace is a pre-Hardmode flail. It has a 1/6 (16.67%) chance to inflict the On Fire! debuff on hit. While the player is in water or the flail's head is submerged, the fire is extinguished and the weapon effectively becomes a regular Mace. Its best modifier is Ruthless. Godly and Demonic may give higher crit chance, but rounding causes Ruthless to have much higher damage for this weapon.
Crafted at By Hand. Ingredients:
Description from the Terraria Wiki.