Terraria item ID 2312. Terraria 1.4.5.7.
Flarefin Koi are a type of pre-Hardmode ((Desktop, Console and Mobile versions)) / Hardmode ((Old-gen console and 3DS versions)) fish which are found very rarely by fishing in any biome in any layer, but only in lava. They are used to craft Seafood Dinners and Inferno Potions.
Description from the Terraria Wiki.