Terraria item ID 43. Terraria 1.4.5.7.
The Suspicious Looking Eye is a boss-summoning item that summons the Eye of Cthulhu when used. It can be used in any biome, but only at night. In addition to being crafted, Suspicious Looking Eyes also have a 1/5 (20%) chance of being found in Ivy Chests and Gold Chests found in the Cavern layer, including locked ones found inside the Dungeon.
Crafted at Demon Altar / Crimson Altar. Ingredients:
Description from the Terraria Wiki.